How to compare a fund commitment with a direct deal on time and information

A fund commitment and a direct deal ask different things of a family. The first question is how much time each one takes. The second is how much the family can see. Richard C. Wilson writes mostly about the direct side, and his writing shows what a direct deal asks for in hours, staff and information[1].

What a direct deal asks of your time

Richard C. Wilson writes that sometimes a family has to move very quickly on a deal. He also writes that thorough due diligence can take weeks, months, and sometimes years[1]. Time on a direct deal can be short at the start and long at the end.

He describes hiring staff to comb through private company information in industries such as healthcare, energy, commercial real estate, or hotels as relatively straightforward and inexpensive[2]. The due diligence and the hands on business building are what become very expensive[2].

An interview in his book describes a basic smell test that every deal must meet. Once a deal passes, the team works on it in a focused manner and within a finite timeframe[1]. The same interview says that closing a few deals a year gives comfort that you are a genuine investor, and that this brings incremental deal flow[1].

What a direct deal shows you

Wilson shares a screening table called the Deal Investment 20. It lists 20 things he looks for while evaluating direct investments and co investments[1]. One item is 100% CEO commitment, not just contributing[1].

He says the table is not a due diligence checklist, which would need to be much more comprehensive[1]. It is for early screening. His team will not meet in person or spend much time on the phone until most if not all of the boxes look fulfilled[1]. A family can use the table with its team or as a way to share its preferences with the people it works with[1].

The contract is another source of information. Wilson writes that a family can compare an ideal or preferred contract with the one it receives, to see which clauses, scenarios and terms need to be completed before signing[1]. He adds that if the other party writes the contract and says everything looks good and ready to sign, you are in trouble[1].

Where a fund commitment fits

The sources give one picture of the fund side. In it, a single person hires and fires fund managers, trades stocks and bonds, manages reporting, and helps coordinate real estate assets and acquisitions[2]. Wilson notes that this family does not get great deal flow, has few formal processes in place, and has not allocated enough resources to protect and manage its capital[2].

This page does not compare fund terms, fees or returns. The sources do not cover them. What they do show is that time and information depend on how much staff and process a family has in place[2].

Ways families add time and information

Wilson lists several options. A family can build a deal sourcing team, form a family investment club, or hire a direct investment executive[2]. A family investment club can be as simple as a quarterly phone call and bi annual meetings to discuss investment ideas, co investment opportunities and marketplace changes. Even three to four families can find it helpful[2].

Wilson also writes that his team sources more than 2,200 deal opportunities a year through family office relationships and its own media and events[2]. One interview in his book adds that deal flow can slow in a bear market, and that this can be a time to look at value[1].

Information can also come as a byproduct. Wilson describes a real estate investment firm that focuses on one square mile and also does leasing, brokerage and management in that area, so it knows when leases are soft and when maintenance is being ignored[3].

Steps you can take

  1. List the hours each option would ask of your principal and your staff.
  2. Write down who would read the reports and track the fund managers.
  3. Screen each direct deal against a short written list of criteria before any meeting.
  4. Set a finite timeframe for working on a deal once it passes a basic smell test.
  5. Compare your preferred contract with the one you receive before signing.
  6. Ask an attorney to review every contract.
  7. Consider a deal sourcing team, a direct investment executive or a family investment club to add capacity.

There are many things to look for, before getting yourself tied up in deep due diligence, and while sometimes you have to move very quickly on a deal, conducting thorough due diligence can take weeks, months, and sometimes years.

Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition) [1]

Questions people ask next

How long can due diligence on a direct deal take?

Richard C. Wilson writes that thorough due diligence can take weeks, months, and sometimes years[1]. He also notes that sometimes a family has to move very quickly[1].

Is the Deal Investment 20 a full due diligence checklist?

No. Wilson says it is not a due diligence checklist, which would need to be much more comprehensive[1]. He describes it as an early screen that a team can use or that a family can use to share its preferences[1].

What costs the most on a direct deal?

Wilson writes that staff to comb through private company information is relatively inexpensive[2]. He says the due diligence and hands on business building become very expensive[2].

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
  2. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
  3. Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies

Related pages

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Billionaires.com. If you want to talk about family offices, principals or an upcoming event, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.

Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Interview quotes are verbatim from recorded interviews or from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list.