How to rebuild trust after a failed deal or a public mistake
A failed deal or a public mistake tests the trust a family has in its own process and in its partners.[1] This guide draws on the writing of Richard C. Wilson, who records how investors react when results fall short of what they were told to expect.[1] It matters for a principal or family office because relationships, committees and portfolio design shape how capital is placed after a setback.[2]
Start with what was expected
One wealth manager interviewed in the book describes the period after the tech wreck.[1] The NASDAQ plummeted by 50%, and the S&P fell close to that.[1] Hedge funds had positive returns in that period.[1] Many investors then wanted to own something with fixed income type risk and equity like returns.[1]
Then 2008 proved that idea wrong.[1] Hedge funds as an asset class dropped by over 20%, as measured by the HFRI index.[1] Generic hedge fund investors said the funds had failed.[1] They had been told that money could be made in up markets and down markets.[1]
The same interviewee points to what those investors failed to understand.[1] The funds did 50% better than the stock market, which was down 40% across the world.[1] Hedge funds were down just 20%.[1] A principal can read this as a reminder to separate the result from the promise that was made.[1]
Rely on people who have earned trust over time
One family office featured in The Single Family Office has an investment committee made up of two full time family members.[2] It also uses outsiders to give insight into potential investment strategies.[2] These are people the family trusts and has built relationships with over time.[2]
That family says it is extremely important to develop a network of people who can help review potential investments.[2] Its deal flow comes in through a few main channels.[2] These include family office conferences and investment conferences.[2] They also include a small group of capital raisers and investment consultants, and the network of other family offices, fund managers and industry insiders.[2] Opportunities from the outside world, such as third party alternative investment funds, are reviewed as well.[2]
The relationships with raisers and consultants were built over the years, and the family respects their insight.[2] Richard C. Wilson calls this a case study in how to efficiently manage a virtual single family office.[2] He also describes a very lean family office that relies upon outside expertise.[2]
Build a portfolio that can absorb a loss
Richard C. Wilson asked family offices for an investment lesson learned the hard way, something they wish they knew 7 or 10 years ago.[2] One answer was to construct a portfolio that is truly panoramic in its allocations.[2] That portfolio has many parts that are uncorrelated or negatively correlated to other parts.[2] A single failure then sits inside a wider structure.[2]
Richard C. Wilson writes that more than 85% of single family offices own operating businesses.[3] Typically these holdings make up 40 to 75% of the family's net worth.[3] One 6th generation family he knows has diversified across a dozen different industries.[3] Others invest only in certain industries, such as commodity businesses, because that is where they first accumulated wealth.[3]
Where families place their trust also changes.[3] In the past, US based family offices had more trust in traditional private equity funds and the public markets.[3] Direct investing is now thriving as a core component of single family offices in the United States.[3] The 2008 hedge fund story adds a related question, which is whether an investment gives correlation benefits to equities and fixed income.[1]
Steps you can take
- Write down what was promised and what was delivered after the failed deal.
- Compare the result with what the wider market did over the same period.
- Name the outside people the family has trusted over time and ask them to review the next deal.
- Keep an investment committee, formal or informal, that includes trusted outsiders.
- Use several deal flow channels, including conferences and long standing relationships.
- Check whether the portfolio has parts that are uncorrelated or negatively correlated to each other.
Questions people ask next
Why do investors call an investment a failure?
In the 2008 example, investors said hedge funds had failed because they had been told money could be made in up and down markets.[1] The funds were down just 20% while the stock market was down 40%.[1]
Who helps a family review a deal after a mistake?
One family office uses an investment committee of two full time family members plus trusted outsiders.[2] It also builds a network of people who can help review potential investments.[2]
How does portfolio design relate to a single failure?
One family office lesson is to build a portfolio with many parts that are uncorrelated or negatively correlated.[2] Richard C. Wilson also notes that one 6th generation family diversified across a dozen industries.[3]
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
Related pages
- How do families rebuild trust after a failed deal?
- What should a family do on Monday after they agree to a large gift or a large deal?
- Should a billionaire family lead a deal or co invest with someone they trust?
- How a family keeps deal flow coming in after the founder steps back
- First 90 days after a liquidity event worksheet
- Direct deal diligence worksheet
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Billionaires.com. If you want to talk about family offices, principals or an upcoming event, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Interview quotes are verbatim from recorded interviews or from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list.