How to share credit inside a family business without confusing ownership

Credit and ownership are two different things, and a family business is clearer when each is handled on its own terms.[1] This page draws on the writing of Richard C. Wilson, who describes how family offices name roles and set up structures when several parties join one deal.[2] For a principal or family office, the point is that a role can be recognized without changing who owns what.[1]

Separate the role from the capital

In a club deal Richard C. Wilson describes, the single family office organizing the deal was the lead investor.[2] The remaining investors were ostensibly passive investors contributing capital only.[2] The lead label described the job of organizing, while the others were defined by the capital they put in.[2] The family needed capital, so it decided to approach other family offices, a few institutional investors and private equity firms.[2]

Wilson writes that in a perfect world the lead family office would have put up 100% of the capital and received 100% of the profits.[1] That would have avoided a structure that lets outside investors pool capital and distribute profits.[1] The club deal let the office take on a deal it could not otherwise swallow.[1] The lead role and the share of capital were two separate questions.[1]

Put ownership in a vehicle built for change

Wilson's direct investing book includes an interview with a family office principal who gives advice on completing a direct investment after due diligence.[2] The advice is to establish an efficient vehicle for acquiring the company or making the investment.[2] The decision should reflect short and long term changes in ownership.[2] It should also reflect potential conflicts in exit timing by different generations or investment partners.[2]

The same advice says the vehicle should be flexible enough to adjust to multiple acquisitions.[2] It should also allow international investors to participate.[2] If possible, an element of liquidity should be included to help attract more co investors, if that is a priority.[2] When ownership sits in a clear vehicle, credit can be discussed without reopening who holds what.[2]

Give decisions a clear home and a shared view

One family office in Wilson's direct investing book describes an investment committee made up of two full time family members.[2] The family also uses outsiders who give insight into potential investment strategies.[2] These are people the family trusts and has built relationships with over time.[2] The same interview calls it extremely important to develop a network of people who can help review potential investments.[2]

Wilson also gathers checklists, tools, assessments and videos into a data room.[3] He hopes families can use these resources to bring advisors or family members onto the same page.[3] One of his suggested strategies is to develop a laser focus based on values, mission, objectives and family history.[3]

Recognize each part for the role it plays

Wilson describes a chess board mindset, which means playing a long term game.[3] Some investments may just grow net worth, others just provide income, and others provide valuable byproducts.[3] One business asset could serve as a pawn, while another is a knight or rook that helps in unexpected ways.[3]

Applied to credit, each part of a family business can be thanked for the role it plays without changing who holds the stake.[3] That keeps recognition and ownership as two separate conversations.[1]

Steps you can take

  1. Write down each person's role in plain words before any talk of ownership.
  2. Label who organizes a deal and who contributes capital only.
  3. Hold ownership in a vehicle that reflects changes across generations.
  4. Plan for conflicts in exit timing between family members and partners.
  5. Name who sits on the investment committee and which outsiders give insight.
  6. Share checklists and tools with advisors and family members so everyone starts from the same page.

In a perfect world, the lead family office would have put up 100% of the capital and received 100% of the profits, without having to set up a structure that allows outside investors to pool capital and distribute profits.

Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office [1]

Questions people ask next

What is the difference between credit and ownership in a family business?

In the club deal Wilson describes, the organizer was the lead investor while the other investors contributed capital only.[2] The structure pooled capital and distributed profits, so the lead role was not the same as owning the whole deal.[1]

Why do generations matter when setting up an ownership vehicle?

The advice Wilson shares says the vehicle should reflect short and long term changes in ownership and potential conflicts in exit timing by different generations or investment partners.[2]

Who takes part in a family investment committee?

One family office in Wilson's book describes a committee of two full time family members.[2] The family also uses trusted outsiders who give insight into potential investment strategies.[2]

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
  2. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
  3. Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies

Related pages

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Billionaires.com. If you want to talk about family offices, principals or an upcoming event, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.

Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Interview quotes are verbatim from recorded interviews or from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list.