How to underwrite an operating business when the seller is also a peer

This guide draws on Richard C. Wilson’s writing about direct investments, operating businesses, liquidity, valuation, and independent review. It matters to principals and family office staff because operating businesses can represent a large part of family wealth, while their value is not realized until cash reaches the owner.[1][2]

Separate the relationship from the review

A seller who is also a peer can bring useful access and context. Family offices may find deal flow through other family offices and through established networks.[2] That connection can help a principal understand the opportunity, but it does not settle what the business is worth.[2][1]

Richard C. Wilson writes that a difference in valuation is a common reason a direct investment stalls. The owner’s view of an attractive price and the buyer’s view of a fair price can differ. Finding a balance is part of completing a direct investment.[1]

Keep the relationship in view while examining the business on its own terms. Wilson describes depth of company and industry knowledge, supported by an independent and objective operational and financial review, as part of understanding a family business.[2] This gives the principal a way to test the seller’s account against a separate review.[2]

Understand the business before setting terms

Start with the company’s operations and finances. Wilson’s writing identifies company and industry knowledge and an independent operational and financial review as inputs to understanding a family business.[2] His writing also notes that family enterprise assets may be managed separately from the family’s wealth portfolio, exposing the family to risks that may go unseen.[2]

The business should also be considered within the wider family portfolio. Wilson describes concentration risk and liquidity risk as matters family offices assess at the portfolio level.[2] He notes that portfolio construction is dynamic and may be adjusted when an opportunity arises.[2]

Consider how the business could fit alongside other family assets. Wilson describes business assets as potentially serving different roles, such as producing income, growing wealth, or providing useful insight about the marketplace.[3] This wider view can help frame what the family values in the opportunity beyond the seller’s price.[3][1]

Protect liquidity and stage capital

Cash flow and liquidity are concerns in direct and co-investments, according to an interview in Wilson’s book. The family office described using surplus funds and limiting debt.[2] For a principal considering an operating business, the relevant question is how much capital can be committed while preserving liquidity for the rest of the portfolio.[2]

Wilson writes that investing in a company in phases can be valuable. Later funding can be tied to milestones, which gives the investor a way to assess progress before committing the next portion of capital.[1] Staging also limits the amount exposed at the outset.[1]

Wilson cautions against putting more money into a business unless it has already been a great success.[1] That point makes follow-on funding a separate decision, informed by the company’s progress, rather than an automatic extension of the initial commitment.[1]

Make the decision with a clear view of tradeoffs

Family offices may be opportunistic, while also monitoring portfolio construction, concentration, and liquidity.[2] Wilson writes that a family office may adjust other operating businesses or revise its plan to accommodate an opportunity.[2] This frames underwriting as both a company review and a decision about the family’s broader assets.[2]

When a seller is a peer, clear valuation work and an independent review can help the parties address differing views of price.[1][2] A staged commitment can then connect capital to milestones, while the family keeps liquidity and portfolio risks in view.[2][1]

Steps you can take

  1. Map the business’s operations and industry.
  2. Arrange an independent operational and financial review.
  3. Compare the seller’s valuation with the buyer’s view of fair value.
  4. Assess the effect on concentration and liquidity across the family portfolio.
  5. Set aside surplus funds for the commitment.
  6. Tie later funding phases to company milestones.
  7. Review follow-on funding separately in light of the company’s results.

It is often valuable to invest in a company through 2 or 3 phases instead of investing all the money upfront.

Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition) [1]

Questions people ask next

Why use an independent review when the seller is a peer?

Richard C. Wilson describes independent and objective operational and financial review, supported by company and industry knowledge, as part of understanding a family business.[2]

How can a family office manage liquidity in a direct investment?

An interview in Wilson’s book describes cash flow and liquidity as concerns and the use of surplus funds with limited debt.[2]

Why stage an investment in an operating business?

Wilson writes that funding in phases can tie later capital to milestones and limit the amount committed at the outset.[1]

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
  2. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
  3. Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies

Related pages

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Billionaires.com. If you want to talk about family offices, principals or an upcoming event, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.

Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Interview quotes are verbatim from recorded interviews or from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list.