How to work with counsel so structure follows purpose, not the other way around
Richard C. Wilson writes about structures such as SPVs, club deals and special purpose entities as tools that serve a goal.[1] He quotes a view that long term success requires understanding both the technical structural issues and the family's own dynamic and culture.[1] For a principal or family office, that means settling what the family wants first and then asking counsel to build the vehicle that fits.[1]
Start with the purpose of the deal
Wilson describes a family that wanted to take over a company and return it to profitability.[2] The deal called for so much capital that the family needed other investors.[2] It chose to approach other family offices, a few institutional investors and private equity firms to see if there was interest in tackling the company as a club.[2] In a perfect world, the lead family office would have put up all the capital and received all the profits, without a structure that lets outside investors pool capital.[2] The club deal let the single family office take on a deal it could not otherwise absorb.[2]
A family office also keeps an ideal portfolio construction plan.[1] Watching concentration risk and liquidity risk is one of its key functions.[1] One office in Wilson's book said it would not pass a good opportunity only because it did not fit that plan.[1] It would look for ways to make the investment while adjusting other parts of the operating businesses, or in the worst case adjusting the plan.[1] The same office says most family offices run by a strong patriarch are opportunistic and do not want too many policies and procedures in the way of a good opportunity.[1]
Put the right questions to counsel
When a family coinvests, Wilson writes that one early question is how the investment will be structured.[2] The choice is specifically whether it will be made through an SPV or a different vehicle.[2] The tax and legal consequences of the structure are very important, especially for foreign investors.[1]
Fees are the next topic.[1] The biggest sticking point usually centers on the fees of the coinvestment.[1] Investors may be willing to pay a management fee but prefer a reduced or wholly eliminated performance fee.[1] Fund managers will try to preserve a fee structure that closely resembles their standard compensation.[1] Wilson says it is up to the two sides to reach an agreement that satisfies both parties and supports a viable long term partnership on the deal.[1]
It helps to know why the other side hesitates.[2] General partners have resisted coinvestment rights because the right adds a layer of complexity to the fund and because other limited partners are more likely to ask for similar arrangements.[2] Family offices ask for these rights for many of the same reasons, including a hope to reduce overall fees on private equity investments.[2]
Structure for the family, not only the deal
Wilson includes a roadmap process that says most family enterprises fail from one generation to the next.[1] The reason given is that family members inadequately address the softer succession planning and behavioral issues, not the business issues.[1] In that process, alternative capital structures are evaluated only after the foundational steps are completed.[1]
The final step creates one or more special purpose entities with specific financial strategies and customized shareholder agreements.[1] These entities house capital distributed from the operating enterprise.[1] With properly designed entities, the process holds that it is possible to mitigate potential capital structure risks and meet both family and family business wealth management and asset protection objectives.[1]
Keep the long game in view
Wilson describes a chess board mindset, which is the mindset of playing a long term game.[3] Some investments grow net worth, others provide income, and others provide valuable byproducts.[3] He writes from the view of an operator and manager of single family offices, not a journalist, professor or consultant.[4]
Steps you can take
- Write down the purpose of the investment or transfer before any structure is discussed.
- Ask counsel whether an SPV or a different vehicle fits that purpose.
- Ask counsel to explain the tax and legal consequences of each structure, especially for foreign investors.
- List the fee terms you would accept and the ones you would resist before you negotiate a coinvestment.
- Review the softer succession and family issues alongside the technical structure.
- Check each proposed structure against your portfolio plan, and decide in advance how you would adjust the plan or the operating businesses for a strong opportunity.
The tax and legal consequences of the structure are very important, especially for foreign investors. The biggest sticking point usually centers on the fees of the co-investment.
Questions people ask next
Why does the structure of a coinvestment matter?
Wilson writes that the tax and legal consequences of the structure are very important, especially for foreign investors.[1] Fees are usually the biggest sticking point.[1]
Why do family offices form club deals?
In the example Wilson gives, the club deal let a single family office take on a deal it could not otherwise absorb.[2] The lead family office organized the deal and the other investors contributed capital.[2]
Why do family enterprises struggle from one generation to the next?
The roadmap process Wilson includes says family members inadequately address the softer succession planning and behavioral issues, not the business issues.[1]
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
Related pages
- How do families work with counsel so legal structure follows a written purpose?
- How should counsel, tax and investment work be coordinated in a small office?
- How a family office coordinates counsel, tax and investment work without a maze
- Family office purpose worksheet
- What should be in a one page purpose statement for a billionaire family office?
- What should a family do when a deal looks attractive but sits off purpose?
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Billionaires.com. If you want to talk about family offices, principals or an upcoming event, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Interview quotes are verbatim from recorded interviews or from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list.