How billionaire families use a shutdown rule before they enter a new venture

This guide explains how families use a shutdown rule to screen ventures that fall outside their investing focus. A clear boundary helps a principal or family office compare an unfamiliar opportunity with the philosophy behind earlier investments before moving forward.[1][2]

Set the boundary before opportunities arrive

Richard C. Wilson writes that families who have kept their wealth often specialize in one, two, or three industries at most. He describes these families as comfortable saying no to opportunities outside those industries because entering an unfamiliar market would depart from the philosophy that guided earlier investments.[1]

That pattern suggests a practical shutdown rule: define the industries and skills that fit the family’s experience, then use those boundaries to screen incoming ventures. Wilson says expanding into a new industry would take an exceptional opportunity, and that he sees experienced families do so rarely.[1]

A rule set in advance gives the family a reference point when a proposal is persuasive or arrives through a trusted relationship. The test is whether the opportunity fits the family’s established areas, or whether it asks the family to abandon its prior investing philosophy.[1]

Write down the investment thesis

Wilson writes that families sometimes cannot clearly state their strategy or the themes they are developing. Newly liquid investors may say they are open to any type of investment, while still having preferences they have not yet put into words.[2]

He connects deal flow with having a clear strike defined for allocations. A family can sort opportunities more quickly when its preferences and investment themes are explicit.[2]

Wilson also describes the value of clarity, focus, and seeing many deals before moving forward on one after a liquidity event. Together, these ideas make the shutdown rule usable: compare each proposal with the written thesis, and pause when the fit is unclear.[2]

Check the structure and the terms

When a family has completed due diligence and is considering a direct investment, the investment vehicle can reflect short and long term changes in ownership. It can also account for possible conflicts in exit timing among different generations or investment partners.[3]

The same discussion identifies flexibility for multiple acquisitions or international investors, and an element of liquidity to help attract co-investors when that is a priority. These are structural considerations to examine alongside whether the venture fits the family’s focus.[3]

Wilson writes that contract clauses, scenarios, and terms need to be completed before signing. He recommends comparing a preferred contract with the one received and having an experienced attorney review the contract.[1][3]

Use the rule to manage scarce attention

Wilson notes that even a well known single family office with a record of bringing products to market still wants more deal flow and does not feel it sees enough ideas. He uses this example to illustrate how little deal flow a less public family may receive.[3]

A defined thesis helps the family sort that flow instead of treating every proposal as equally relevant. Wilson’s writing links clarity and focus with seeing many deals before moving forward on one.[2]

The shutdown rule can therefore serve as a repeatable screen. If a venture sits outside the family’s areas and does not meet the exceptional standard for expansion, the family can decline it and keep attention on proposals that fit its stated focus.[1][2]

Steps you can take

  1. Write down the industries and skills that fit the family’s experience.
  2. State the family’s investment themes and preferences in plain language.
  3. Compare each new venture with the written investment thesis.
  4. Decide what would qualify as an exceptional reason to enter a new industry.
  5. Review ownership changes, exit timing, flexibility, and liquidity in the investment vehicle.
  6. Compare the proposed contract with the preferred terms and have an experienced attorney review it.
  7. See many opportunities before moving forward on one.

These families are very comfortable saying “no” to investment opportunities outside these industries. To do so would be to abandon the philosophy that guided previous investments and to enter a market that is wholly unfamiliar to the family.

Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office [1]

Questions people ask next

What is the shutdown rule?

It is a screening boundary based on the family’s established industries, skills, and investing philosophy. Wilson writes that experienced families are comfortable declining opportunities outside their areas.[1]

When might a family consider a new industry?

Wilson describes expansion into a new industry as rare for experienced families and says it would take an exceptional opportunity.[1]

What should a family review before signing?

Wilson writes that clauses, scenarios, and terms need to be completed before signing. He recommends comparing the received contract with preferred terms and having an experienced attorney review it.[1][3]

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
  2. Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies
  3. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)

Related pages

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Billionaires.com. If you want to talk about family offices, principals or an upcoming event, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.

Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Interview quotes are verbatim from recorded interviews or from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list.