What is a shutdown condition, and why set it before a new venture starts?
A shutdown condition is a stated point at which a venture ends or is exited, decided before the venture begins[1]. One family office practice is to consider how to exit an investment, and when, at the outset[1]. Richard C. Wilson also writes that families gain from clarity about what they want before they move on a deal[2].
Planning the exit at the start
In one family office approach, each new investment is clearly set apart from the family office at the outset, so liabilities of the business do not flow over to the family office[1]. Generally a separate legal entity is set up for the activity, and each new investment is placed in its own silo[1]. The same approach asks how the investment can be exited and when[1]. It is described as more art than science, and still a critical exercise[1].
A family office interview in the same book adds a point about structure. The vehicle used to make an investment should reflect changes in ownership over time[1]. It should also allow for possible conflicts in exit timing between generations or investment partners[1].
Why clarity comes before the first deal
Richard C. Wilson writes that when families are asked about their strategy and the themes they are developing, many do not have a clear answer[2]. He compares this to a graduate who says any business job is fine, then quickly learns what they do not like[2]. Most investors have many preferences, and they have not written them down or voiced them yet[2].
Wilson also points to a short recording on not moving too quickly into deals after a liquidity event[2]. The advice there is to gain clarity and focus, and to see many deals before moving forward on one[2]. A condition for stopping or exiting is one more preference a family can write down early.
Setting limits and criteria
One family office describes its early years as basic due diligence and a lot of gut feel, with no real criteria for investment decisions[1]. Over time it put systems and processes in place with a clear focus[1]. One of its first choices was to invest only where it believed it added value, through domain knowledge or geographic expertise[1].
Another family office says it helps to first set parameters for the kind and size of deals it wants[1]. That thought process then shapes how deals are introduced[1]. Wilson notes that the size or terms of an investment round may not line up with an ideal portfolio construction plan, so written limits give a family something to measure each round against[1].
You cannot thrive in the flow of investment opportunities as an ultra-wealthy family if you do not have a good strike defined for your allocations.
Questions people ask next
Why keep a new venture separate from the family office?
One family office places each new investment in its own silo, usually under a separate legal entity, so liabilities of the business do not flow over to the family office[1].
Can exit timing cause conflict?
One family office interview says the investing vehicle should reflect possible conflicts in exit timing between generations or investment partners[1].
Why write down preferences before investing?
Richard C. Wilson writes that most investors have many preferences they have not written down and voiced yet[2]. He adds that a family needs a good strike defined for its allocations to do well in the flow of opportunities[2].
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies
Related pages
- How billionaire families use a shutdown rule before they enter a new venture
- What should next generation members learn before they join an investment committee?
- What should be on a short checklist before traveling to see a deal?
- What should a family write down before they allocate capital after a sale?
- What questions should a family ask before taking a deal from a friend?
- How do families use written shutdown rules in a new business line?
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes Billionaires.com. If you want to talk about family offices, principals or an upcoming event, reach him directly. There is no form on this site.
Educational content only. Not investment, tax or legal advice. Interview quotes are verbatim from recorded interviews or from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list.